Compare pension lump sum vs annuity payments with lifetime income analysis, breakeven age calculation, and survivor benefit evaluation. Calculate total payout, investment return requirements, inflation impact, and tax implications to determine optimal pension election for retirement security in 2025.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I take my pension as a lump sum or annuity in 2025?

Pension decision depends on 5 key factors (2025 analysis): (1) Breakeven age: If annuity total payments exceed lump sum before age 80-85, annuity wins for longevity.

Example: $500k lump sum vs $30k/year annuity → Breakeven = $500k / $30k = 16.7 years.

If retire at 65, break even at age 81.7.

Live to 90 → Annuity pays $750k total (25 years × $30k) vs $500k lump sum = $250k more with annuity. (2) Investment return assumption: Can you earn >6% annually on lump sum? 2025 reality: S&P 500 historical 10% but with 20% volatility.

Conservative 60/40 portfolio ~7% return.

If you can reliably earn 7-8% and withdraw 4% annually (safe withdrawal rate), lump sum may outperform.

Example: Invest $500k at 7%, withdraw $30k/year → Portfolio lasts 35+ years, leaves $200k inheritance. (3) Health/longevity: Family history of longevity (parents lived to 90+) favors annuity (guaranteed income for life).

Poor health or life expectancy <80 favors lump sum (can pass to heirs if you die early, annuity payments stop). (4) Spousal protection: Joint-and-survivor annuity (pays 50-100% to spouse after your death) provides security vs lump sum that could be mismanaged/depleted. (5) Inflation protection: Most pensions lack COLA (Cost of Living Adjustment). $30k/year at 3% inflation = $22,200 purchasing power in 10 years.

Lump sum allows equity allocation for inflation hedge. 2025 recommendation: Take annuity if offered rate >6% implied return, have longevity, need guaranteed income security.

Take lump sum if <6% implied return, good investment discipline, want flexibility/inheritance.

About This Page

Editorial & Updates

  • Author: SuperCalc Editorial Team
  • Reviewed: SuperCalc Editors (clarity & accuracy)
  • Last updated: 2026-01-13

We maintain this page to improve clarity, accuracy, and usability. If you see an issue, please contact hello@supercalc.dev.

Financial/Tax Disclaimer

This tool does not provide financial, investment, or tax advice. Calculations are estimates and may not reflect your specific situation. Consider consulting a licensed professional before making decisions.